Sex and coal

Reading the below and Lori Adorable I was reminded of an old Chris Dillow post, coal not dole. What would happen if Sweden were successful and ended demand for paid sex?

Some say sex workers will find other work, Lori says this is ridiculous. Lots of sex workers say we need to end violence, not demand. I say, because I’m a bit weird, what’s the evidence from Britain’s coalfields?

Since the beginning of the 1980s the British coal industry has lost around a quarter of a million jobs, largely because demand for coal from deep mines vanished. The analogy isn’t great, but it crossed my mind and I haven’t had a decent idea for a blog post in five months. Sue me. So, it turns out, of the 213,000 mining jobs lost since 1985, 90,000 have not been replaced. The miners were promised that Thatcher’s glorious entrepreneurial Britain would find them new jobs. It did not.

The market failed Britain’s old labour aristocracy and the state did little better. When Thatcher’s job machine stalled at Watford Gap Blair’s public sector investment helped. Of the 90,000 jobs created, many came only because  of intensive investment by local authorities, development agencies, central government and the European Union. More than half of these 90,000 jobs were created since 2001.

If demand for something disappears it should reappear somewhere else. But that doesn’t mean those left without work will benefit. It might be easy to assume the market will allocate labour effectively if a job disappears, but much of the evidence we have suggests otherwise.

Miners were economically organised, politically powerful, physically healthy and ultimately received significant investment in jobs. Despite all this communities remain scarred to this day. What would be the result of a end to demand for sex workers who are more politically and economically isolated, more absent from the media, and often physically and mentally unable to do other work? I’ve had five months off, so I’m a little rusty. I will leave the rest of this nasty little thought experiment as an exercise for the reader.